Today’s Show:Are High End Audio/Video Retailers a Dying Breed?We all know someone who has to own the absolute best gear on the market. They don’t care how much it costs. Whether its a receiver that “reproduces sounds that only dogs can hear” or its the guy who buys the most expensive video processor for his equally expensive projector, we all have stories of friends or acquaintances that match that description. Do you remember chains that focused solely on A/V. We all remember The Good Guys, Tweeter, and in Southern California Ken Crane’s just to name a few. Today many of us buy our electronics at Best Buy, Costco, Wal*Mart, or online from Amazon. You have to look hard to find a brick and mortar store that exclusively sells A/V equipment. What’s going on? Do we no longer care about quality audio and video? Or more likely, equipment has become much better and we can now have a high quality experience from low price gear. VideoLet’s take a look at TVs first. Ara’s first HDTV (which is still in use) was a $4,000 DLP that measured 50 inches. Three years later Ara bought another DLP for his media room. It measured 65 inches and cost $2,000. It produces a picture that is dramatically improved over the 50 inch DLP. Both are properly calibrated. Two years ago Ara bought a 37 inch LCD TV that produced a better picture out of the box than the $4000 DLP. The point here being that TVs have become so good you don’t have to spend a lot of money for very high quality. In fact, videophile grade Plasmas and projectors can be had for less than what Ara paid for his original DLP. Please don’t misunderstand what we are saying. There are still very high end TVs that cost much more than $4,000, we’re just saying that there isn’t much difference between the top of the line consumer grade and Videophile products. And as such, there is no reason to visit a specialty store to purchase your TV. Next we’ll look at Blu Ray players. Even the cheapest Blu Ray player will produce a picture that is superior to the best DVD player; provided that the Blu Ray disc was masted properly. That means for $99 we can have a picture that looks better than the most expensive DVD player produced just 5 years ago. Are there premium players on the market today, sure. But the cost is usually in the upconversion process of DVDs. If you are all Blu Ray, then you have videophile quality without the price. Why would you spend $1000 on a Blu Ray player when it won’t produce a significantly better picture than the $100 player? AudioA similar argument can be applied to audio equipment. Just two years ago if you wanted to get into the next generation audio game you needed to shell out a minimum of $1000. Today a $300 receiver from Pioneer, Yamaha, or Onkyo can do the same thing. What about sound leveling, auto calibration, height channels, and seven channels? Once the domain of expensive high end gear, all these features are available in receivers that go for $700. The only place we haven’t seen a dramatic decline in prices are speakers. Good speakers can make a $500 receiver sound like $1000 receiver. The converse is true also so don’t cheap out when buying speakers. The good news is with all the money you save on your TV, Blu Ray Player, and Receiver, you can afford a good set of speakers. This is an area that a good specialty store can provide a service. But even still, as good as speakers sound in a store, they will sound differently when you get them home. Some online speaker companies will give you a no risk 30 day free in home trial. That way you can hear exactly how they will sound in your home. No guessing! What does this all mean?Unless high end retailers can provide some sort of reason for you to spend money in their stores, they are going to find themselves out of business. These stores typically charge more for their products than Best Buy or online retailers. Jerry Del Colliano has some ideas in his article Is Today’s Home Theater Equipment Too Good? A/V Retailers need to:
We’d add they need to provide door to door service. Buy the TV this afternoon watch it tonight, on a calibrated and fully installed system. One of the last sentences in his article sums it up beautifully, “If the AV business cannot more clearly illustrate why specialty audio is in fact special, then expect more stores and regional chains to fold in the coming months even as the economy improves, simply perhaps fueled by the fact that mainstream home theater gear is just too good.” Reader Commentarytnsprin • Jul 30, 5:20am Actually when my bread is dying, I toast it. Its been at least 15 years since I actually went in to a B and M High End AV retailer. For a while I was finding that I still had to make puchase my equipment via Mail Order and later internet from one of them. But now of days it is mostly a question of finding who has the lowest price (after taxes and shipping) via internet and ordering it from them. Some times that means its still one of high end stores, e.g 3 years ago it was Twitter for a 55" HdTV, but this year it was Amazon for a 3d HDTV.... Shane • Jul 30, 7:57am Corrected the spelling ... thanks :-) - Shane... paulsquillo • Jul 30, 9:51am Thanks for fixing the spelling. Now if we could get you guys to listen long enough to notice that most AV systems in people's homes these days sound no better than the cheap starter systems that we (as audio/video specialists) were selling in the mid-70's. And I'm not just talking about Home Theater in a Box or plastic mini-systems. It's not about perfect calibration of junk that can't ever show the subtle qualities of a fine piece of music. It's not about same day delivery. It's about goosebumps every time you listen. It's about wanting to hear every old recording that you own over and over, because you notice something wonderful and new each time you listen. It's about a home system that is so good, you are inspired to go to hear more great live music events (hopefully not through a lousy PA system). And to search out the world's finest recordings. Don't tell people there's no difference just because you were raised on computer speakers. Spend a month exploring the ... akirby • Jul 30, 2:00pm Paul - I agree that there is a difference with high end equipment. In some cases a big difference. Here is the problem - 90% can't hear the difference and 9% can hear the difference but just don't care. That's why mp3s are so popular. True audiophiles are rare. 1% is probably way too optimistic.... paulsquillo • Jul 30, 3:28pm First of all, almost everybody can hear the difference. Whenever a client tells me they can't, I ask them this question: "If there was a person playing a set of drums, or a string quartet, around the corner in the next room from you in your home, would you be able to tell if it was real vs. just a recording?" Almost everyone knows without a doubt that they can! The trouble is, nobody gives themselves permission to expect that true a sound from their audio system. As soon as they sit down with the expectation that they should hear live quality from their systems, they suddenly notice all of the things that don't sound real. Audio can be great, and even very inexpensive systems that are well-designed and assembled can give people the ability to fall into the music. The less expensive systems rely more on the brain's ability to correct for the differences. Each step better, and the brain has to do less work. You hear more, and listening is less fatiguing. Where we can ... alice • Jul 31, 5:01pm
Finally a breath of Fresh Air. Someone is actually promoting quality equipment and standing up to supporting audiophile and videophile standards Personally have found that if you take the time to educate your client that they do see & hear the difference. Yes we know that there are many who did not care yet they can shown to appreciate the value. A major problem is going for the quick buck and then Joe expects the cheap price . Competing on price is a losing strategy. As an example of education, have turned a 12 yr old in budding audiophile . After having playing her favourites as mp3's and then as Flac files, she now only listens to Flac files recorded at 320kps. The ipod has been restocked with 320k material. When i told her the next step was a dac for outputting the ipod to the main stereo , the eyes light up and her first words "when can we do that" . She is looking at the peachtree and few others in the 1,000 plus range .... More from The HT Guys
More in Category: High Definition Production
About The HT GuysThe HT Guys, Ara Derderian and Braden Russell, are Engineers who formerly worked for the Advanced Digital Systems Group (ADSG) of Sony Pictures Entertainment. ADSG was the R&D unit of the sound department producing products for movie theaters and movie studios.Two of the products they worked on include the DCP-1000 and DADR-5000. The DCP is a digital cinema processor used in movie theaters around the world. The DADR-5000 is a disk-based audio dubber used on Hollywood sound stages. ADSG was awarded a Technical Academy Award by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences in 2000 for the development of the DADR-5000. Ara holds three patents for his development work in Digital Cinema and Digital Audio Recording. Every week they put together a podcast about High Definition TV and Home Theater. Each episode brings news from the A/V world, helpful product reviews and insights and help in demystifying and simplifying HDTV and home theater. |
advertisement
Local Guides
Authors
Categories
Other Recent Discussion
advertisement
|
||||||||